When a mechanical failure causes or adds to a car accident in California, one or more parties besides the other driver may be legally responsible for your injuries. It depends on why the failure happened. The vehicle manufacturer may be liable if a defective part failed. Whoever maintains the vehicle may be liable if poor maintenance let a hazardous condition develop. A repair shop may be liable if improper service created a dangerous condition. Attorney Damoun Yazdi at The Accident Network Law Group investigates mechanical failure accident liability throughout Southern California.

Key Takeaways

  • Vehicle manufacturers can be held strictly liable under California law when defective parts cause accidents
  • Negligent maintenance by a vehicle owner, fleet operator, or repair shop can also create liability
  • Common mechanical failures in accident cases include brake failure, tire blowouts, steering defects, and accelerator malfunctions
  • You do not need to prove the manufacturer was careless in strict product liability cases, only that the product was defective
  • California’s two-year statute of limitations (CCP Section 335.1) applies; mechanical failure evidence must be preserved quickly

Types of Mechanical Failures That Cause Accidents

Brake failures are among the most common mechanical causes of traffic accidents. Brake systems can fail due to manufacturing defects, worn brake pads or rotors that were not replaced, hydraulic fluid leaks, and improper installation during a brake service. When a vehicle loses braking ability, the driver may be unable to stop at intersections, avoid rear-end collisions, or maintain control on downhill grades.

Tire failures, including blowouts and tread separation, can cause sudden loss of vehicle control. Tire failures may result from manufacturing defects, improper installation, underinflation, overloading beyond the tire’s rated capacity, and failure to replace tires worn beyond safe limits. California law requires minimum tire tread depth, and operating a vehicle with worn tires may be evidence of negligent maintenance.

Steering system failures prevent the driver from controlling the vehicle’s direction. Power steering component failures, tie rod failure, and worn ball joints can cause sudden steering loss. These failures may result from manufacturing defects, wear that was not addressed during maintenance, or corrosion.

Accelerator malfunctions that cause unintended acceleration (where the throttle sticks open) can make a vehicle nearly uncontrollable. Accelerator defects have been the subject of major automotive recalls. If a recall was issued for your vehicle and the defect was not repaired, the manufacturer’s liability may be strengthened.

Suspension failures that cause a vehicle to handle unpredictably, particularly in emergency maneuvers or sudden directional changes, can result from worn shock absorbers, broken springs, and failed control arm bushings.

Who Is Liable for Mechanical Failure Accidents

Vehicle Manufacturers: California’s strict product liability doctrine, established in Greenman v. Yuba Power Products (1963), allows injured parties to hold manufacturers liable when a product is defective and the defect causes injury. Strict liability means you do not need to prove the manufacturer was negligent. You must show the product was defective when it left the manufacturer’s control and the defect caused your injuries.

The three types of product defects are design defects (the design itself is inherently dangerous even when manufactured correctly), manufacturing defects (an error in production created a product that deviates from the intended design), and warning defects (failure to provide adequate warnings about known risks).

Repair Shops: When a mechanic performs work incorrectly, fails to identify a dangerous condition they should have caught, or recommends a repair is unnecessary when it is critical for safety, they can be liable for accidents resulting from the uncorrected or improperly repaired condition.

Vehicle Owners and Fleet Operators: Commercial vehicle owners (trucking companies, rental car companies, government fleets) have a duty to maintain their vehicles properly. If a commercial vehicle causes an accident due to a maintenance failure, the operator may face direct liability for negligent maintenance in addition to the driver’s potential liability.

How to Build a Mechanical Failure Liability Case

Preserving evidence is the most urgent step. Vehicle components and systems involved in the accident must be examined before they are repaired, altered, or destroyed. Your attorney can send a spoliation (evidence preservation) letter to the other parties and their insurers requiring them to preserve the vehicle.

An automotive forensic engineer or accident reconstruction expert can analyze the vehicle components to determine whether a mechanical defect existed and whether it caused or contributed to the accident. This expert testimony is often the core of a mechanical failure liability case.

Maintenance records, recall records, and prior repair orders are discoverable in litigation. If the vehicle was subject to a recall that was never completed, the recall records become critical evidence.

California Laws Relevant to Mechanical Failure Claims

California Civil Code Section 1714 establishes the general duty of care. California’s strict product liability doctrine (Greenman, 1963) applies when a manufacturing defect caused the failure. California Code of Civil Procedure Section 335.1 sets the two-year statute of limitations. California follows pure comparative negligence (Li v. Yellow Cab Co., 1975). California Vehicle Code Section 16056 (amended by SB 1107, effective January 1, 2025) sets minimum auto insurance at $30,000/$60,000/$15,000.

NM

Nathan Metcalfe

★★★★★

My car accident was chaotic, but Damoun provided clarity and order in the aftermath. Highly recommended for anyone who needs a professional to help them on their case.

Contact The Accident Network Law Group About a Mechanical Failure Claim

If a mechanical failure contributed to your accident, Attorney Damoun Yazdi at The Accident Network Law Group, with 12+ years of experience and a background as a former law clerk at the LA County District Attorney’s Office, can coordinate the investigation to preserve the vehicle, retain a forensic engineer, and identify every liable party, whether that is the manufacturer, a repair shop, or a fleet operator. Free consultations and a contingency fee basis mean there is no upfront cost to you.

Our team serves Riverside, Costa Mesa, Rancho Cucamonga, Apple Valley, Victorville, and Bakersfield, and throughout Southern California. Se habla espanol.

Legal Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The outcome of any case depends on its specific facts and circumstances. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact The Accident Network Law Group for advice about your individual situation.