Security camera footage is some of the strongest evidence in a California personal injury case. A video of a slip and fall, car accident, or assault can prove exactly how an incident happened and who is responsible. It often settles liability disputes that would otherwise come down to conflicting testimony. But security footage is often overwritten within days to weeks unless someone saves it quickly. If you were hurt and think security cameras caught the incident, act right away.
Key Takeaways
- Security footage on many commercial systems is stored on a rolling loop and can be overwritten quickly, so requesting preservation immediately is critical
- You can request footage through an attorney demand letter (spoliation letter) to preserve and produce the footage
- California Evidence Code Sections 1560 through 1567 govern how a business must respond to a subpoena for its business records, which can include video surveillance
- Private individuals and businesses are generally not required to voluntarily hand over footage without a litigation hold or subpoena
- A personal injury attorney can send a preservation demand letter that creates a legal duty to retain footage before it is overwritten
Why Timing Is Critical
Many commercial security systems record on a rolling loop and automatically overwrite older footage to save storage space. The exact retention window varies widely by system and business, from a few days at high activity locations to several weeks at lower traffic systems, so there is no single universal deadline. If you or your attorney do not act to preserve the footage in time, it may be permanently lost. Courts have held that once a business receives notice that footage is relevant to potential litigation, destroying or allowing it to be overwritten can constitute spoliation of evidence, which may result in adverse inference jury instructions or sanctions against the responsible party.
How to Request Security Camera Footage
Through your attorney: The most effective preservation method is having Attorney Damoun Yazdi send a written litigation hold, or spoliation, letter to the property owner, business, or government entity immediately after your injury. This letter formally notifies the recipient that the footage is relevant to anticipated litigation and demands preservation. Failure to comply after receiving such a letter can expose the recipient to spoliation sanctions.
Through a formal public records request: If the footage is held by a California government agency, such as city traffic cameras, law enforcement dash cameras, or Caltrans cameras, a request under the California Public Records Act (Government Code Section 7920.000 et seq., recodified from former Section 6250 et seq.) may be available. Government agencies generally must determine whether records are disclosable within 10 days of a request, with a possible 14 day extension in unusual circumstances.
Through subpoena in litigation: Once a lawsuit is filed, your attorney can serve a formal subpoena on the business or government agency requiring production of the footage under Evidence Code Sections 1560 through 1567, which govern production of business records. Failure to respond is enforceable by the court.
Who May Have Relevant Footage
Depending on where your accident occurred, potential sources include the business where the incident happened (retail stores, restaurants, gas stations, parking garages), neighboring businesses whose cameras cover adjacent areas, traffic cameras maintained by Caltrans or local municipalities, ATM cameras, bank cameras, or building security systems, and residential doorbell camera systems (Ring, Nest, Arlo) from nearby homes.
Attorney Damoun Yazdi’s team identifies all potential footage sources and deploys preservation demands immediately upon being retained in an injury case.
Esperanza Benitez
Contact The Accident Network Law Group
Security footage disappears fast, so do not wait to get help. Attorney Damoun Yazdi and The Accident Network Law Group can send an immediate preservation demand to protect the video evidence in your case. Consultations are free and available 24/7, and we work on a No Recovery, No Fee basis, serving clients from offices in Costa Mesa, Riverside, Rancho Cucamonga, Apple Valley, Victorville, and Bakersfield. Se habla espanol.
This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The outcome of any case depends on its specific facts and circumstances. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact The Accident Network Law Group for advice about your individual situation.
